Earthquakes and Glass Insulators
by P. Quentin Tomich
Reprinted from "INSULATORS - Crown Jewels of the Wire", June 1973, page 13
The "Big Island" of Hawaii is in an earthquake zone, and seismic
motion is generated from shifts of the earth's crustal plates as well as from
molten lava moving locally underground. Mild jiggles and an occasional jolt may
occur several times a year. Ever since my insulator collection began to grow
onto shelves I have been concerned that some reasonable precautions should be
taken against damage from earthquakes.
The insulators are displayed on (1) wall shelves, (2) window shelves, and (3)
on representative styles of crossarms. The collection is now creeping out of our
hobby alcove and around into the utility area. On open wall shelves I drove a
6-penny common nail every 3 1/2 inches so an insulator can be placed over each
nail. This spacing is satisfactory for the general run of sizes that fit on a 1 x 4 shelf. The large flat head of the nail tends to catch the threads of the
insulator, so the common nail is probably better than a finish nail. My 4 x 9
display window has an outside grill made from 3-inch gratings out of a rock
crusher, no glass, and ordinary fly screen on the inside. Shelves are set
between the iron grill and plastic screen. Insulators display very well this
way, and it is not a burden to remove the screen frame to work on them. The
crossarms are variously screwed or bracketed to the wall or mounted on an old
square-sawed redwood pole.
The fairly severe earthquake (6.2 Richter) that rocked Hawaii on April 26,
1973 provided a test case and even some statistical results on my attempts at
protecting the collection. The epicenter of the quake is 27 miles down the coast
from us, so we were fairly close in. We have a frame house (single-wall vertical
t&g), and the floor is concrete in the hobby-utility area. To generalize,
pony type or other tall sorts of insulators are more likely to tumble than are
signals or others with a broad skirt; insulators near the ceiling are dislodged
easier than those near the floor; a concrete floor is a real hazard to any glass
that falls.
The CD 121, 122, 126, 133, 134, 151 series had the worst casualties. Of 96 on
three shelves 6 to 7 feet above the floor (with nails), 44 or nearly 46% fell
down. There was a remarkable difference with the CD 145, 162, 164 series at the
same level. Of 154 on nails, only 13 (8.4%) fell. A row of CD 154, 155's on a
sill a foot above the floor, without nails, (a calculated risk) stood pretty
well, and only 5 out of 39 fell, with only a minor bruise or two. Among the CD
102, 106, 112 series within 3 feet of the floor and on nails, 4 out of 60 (6.7%)
dropped. My best pieces are kept in the display window where the shelves have no
nails, or firmly on crossarm pins. In spite of considerable sliding around in
the windows, there was no damage there, and those on pins also rode out the
quake perfectly. The work table and chairs, and appliances in the utility area,
no doubt prevented some direct falls on the concrete and saved several prized
insulators. Of the total of 136 that fell, 31 were unscathed, 22 had minor
damage, and 83 were demolished. I may be able to piece some of them back
together. Anyone want a genuine earthquake damaged insulator?
Possibly other collectors will profit from this report of my recent
experience, and it should suggest ideas for improvement and perhaps some
innovation. Earthquakes are a reality. Larger nails, possibly 10 or even 16
penny, could be tried. Taller insulators can be placed nearer to the floor, and
a carpeted wood floor would certainly improve survival of insulators that do
fall. If you are anticipating something stronger than a 6.2, you might store a
few gems under your pillow.
|