Porcelain Insulator News
by Jack H. Tod, NIA #13
Reprinted from "INSULATORS - Crown Jewels of the Wire", October 1979, page 22
Gerald Brown (Colorado) didn't believe me when I said my
crystal ball indicated he'd better take a big supply (a very big supply) of his
new book to the Denver N.I.A. Convention. He had people waiting in line to
obtain the book until he sold out the "big" supply he took with him,
and then he just started taking addresses to mail copies to those who weren't
nimble enough to get in line quick enough.
I doubt that the book will be
reprinted when the supply is exhausted. If you miss out getting a copy of the
book, don't say I didn't warn you!
Jack
Jerry Turner of Goshen, Ohio (Past
Pres., N.I.A.) sent a newsy letter to bring us up to date. Both Jerry and
Marilyn have changed positions in the fall of 1978. Jerry is now with Durocraft
Products Inc., Cincinnati (Manufacturing, V.P. of Sales). Marilyn is chief of
quality control section of a machine shop only two miles from the Goshen
homestead. The rest of the family are all doing fine.
Jerry mentioned a list of
goodies he's obtained in the past year, and it makes one drool.
He acquired
another U-709A Pittsburg with an incuse hand-stamp marking, but this one has a
type face resembling a fancy Old English, something like we've sketched above --
uite different from the other marked Pittsburgs reported in the past.
I'm sure this was a welcome addition for Jerry, since he's always been a real
collecting fan of Pittsburg porcelains.
Another interesting item Jerry got at
the Friendship, Indiana flea market is a pottery canning jar with the marking
shown at the right (jar bottom).
Gerald Brown told me about eight years ago that
when he was researching Illinois Electric Porcelain Co., Macomb, Ill. he had
learned there had been at least two other "potteries" there in the
past. Here's proof of the pudding. Although not connected in any way (that we
know of!) with insulators, this jar is a nice shelf item for anyone interested
in Macomb items.
Jerry also said that it was hard to believe, but he
counted six porcelain U-407 Jumbos in the exhibits and on sales tables at the
10th N.I.A. National Convention in Denver (July 1979). This U-407 is not a rare
item still, but it does show how many goodies do make their appearance at the
annual N.I.A. National.
Jerry also acquired another U-407 with the LOCKE
handstamp marking at the Washington Court House (Ohio) flea market. This came
from a friend there who had obtained it in a collection he bought in
Pennsylvania. Trying to corner the market, Jerry?
Jerry got a brown U-944 at the
Denver show. This is an early classic glazeweld by THOMAS. It's a rare item in
white glaze, and even rarer with brown glaze.
Then there was a cute little U-442
made by Pittsburg (specimen unmarked). This was a big surprise to both Jerry and
me. We've collected Pittsburg items for a long time, not to mention many
weekends of digging in the old Pittsburg factory dumpage, but this is really
something different for Ptsbg. We never dreamed they made small cables such as
this one.
These are probably just the goodies Jerry told me about. No telling
what else he's holding back on us!
Jack
Two more Pittsburg "date
control" markings have been reported since our request in July 1979 CJ for
help in trying to solve the date coding puzzle. Both markings were on P.R.
"hat" distribution insulators.
Jack Gooden, Jr. (Medford, N.Y.) has
one with a marking of "JUL 26 ANS'D" on the dome.
Ben Kirsten (Grand
Junction, Colo.) has a similar one with "AUG 12 REC'D" on the
dome.
We're getting very close to having enough of these date stamps to crack
the year coding used by Pittsburg. If just several of you can jot down on a
postcard the datestamp marking on your Pittsburg specimen, we may have success
in this venture. Please??
Jack
Dear Jack:
The enclosed picture is of an
item I found a while back. I thought it might be of interest to CJ readers who
collect the insulator go-with item.
It was described to me as a "choke
coil". The idea was to mount it on the crossarm and connect it in series
with the primary wire so the line current would flow through the coil (normal
current up to the nameplate rating of 50 amps). When the current exceeded the
rating (as with lightning), the current flowing through the coil produced a
field which opposed this flaw, thereby "choking" or reducing the
transient current peak.
I am not positive that this was the correct way in which
these units were used., but I have never seen any in service anywhere, so I
can't disagree. If you have any more information (correct use, date of use,
value, or whatever), I would be interested in finding out.
The whole assembly is
constructed on a piece of 3" channel iron 17" long. The large coil is
3" outside diameter and made of AWG #2 copper wire. The husky terminals are
cemented into the pin holes of a pair of ordinary pin type porcelains attached
inverted to the base. Riveted to the side of the channel iron base is a
nameplate reading as follows:
ELECTRIC SERVICE SUPPLIES CO.
PHILADELPHIA - NEW
YORK - CHICAGO
TYPE LU No.50457 VOLTS 3000 AMP 50
Frank Shore
Tucson, Arizona
- - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Frank:
I don't have an answer for what this very interesting
"gismo" is, but maybe one of our elder linemen or electrical engineers
out there can write and tell us. One thing for sure is that it must be a real eye-catcher
sitting there with your insulator collection. I can't make a guess as
to "value" of any such oddball items that turn up out of the blue.
Their value depends on the combined thoughts of both seller and buyer -- if a
transaction does take place.
I can't guess its vintage, but E.S.S. Co. was in
business from 1906 until at least the 1930's. Woodward didn't have in his book
data on this company, but I have at least some and will give it below for the
benefit of collectors of both glass and porcelain insulators.
Electric
Service Supplies Co. was established in 1906: President, Charles G. Mayer; V.P.
& Treasurer, A. H, Englund -- both formerly of Mayer & Englund Co.
(1901-1906, also of Philadelphia). I always just assumed this was the same
company with merely a corporate name change.
Knowles cable insulators were
jobbed with an embossed M. & E. Co. marking, and then later with the E. S.
S. Co. marking after 1906. The company probably jobbed porcelain pin types of
one or more companies throughout the years, but a 1928 catalog shows they were
then jobbing the complete line of Franklin Porcelain Co. insulators. Franklin
was located in Norristown near Philadelphia, and there may have been more than a
supplier-dealer relationship between the companies.
E.S.S. Co. used the word
"KEYSTONE" as a trademark (registered #65,586, 10/8/07) and also later
a keystone symbolic logo (registered #80,769, 1/31/11; reregistered #266,285,
1/14/30). Of very special interest is the trademark tie-in with the former Mayer
& Englund Co., since the registration showed "used since" dates
from 1906 thru 1926 for various equipment, plus the conspicuous date of 1901 for
"Trolley Insulators etc." [Was the M &, E Co. address also at 17th
& Cambria Sts. in Philadelphia??]
The E.S.S. Co. main office and factory was
located at 17th & Cambria Streets, Philadelphia, Pa. (Don't all you dump
diggers get there the same weekend!). They had sales offices in six other U.S.
cities plus three in Canada.
Other than that, I know nothing more about the
company.
Jack
HELP!
Does anyone have an old catalog of Virginia Pottery Co., New
Lexington, Ohio?? I know they exist, because someone told me a number of years
ago they'd seen one in the hands of another collector. If so, can we merely
borrow it to make prints. If you don't trust to mail it, then I'll pay your
costs in making Xerox prints of the pages and mailing them.
I am also very
anxious to locate any copies of catalogs issued by THOMAS before 1900, and
especially any pre-1896.
I would very much like to hear from anyone who has
catalogs or access to trade journals with drawings, photos, sketches or
descriptions of pin type insulators made before 1900 by either of the following:
Electrical Porcelain & Manufacturing Co. (Trenton, NJ); Peru Electric
Manufacturing Co. (Peru, Ind.); General Electric Co. (Schenectady, NY). I will
reimburse you for print and mailing costs if you have any such information.
Jack
Dear Jack:
Enclosed are pictures of several insulators. The first (at
right) seems to be a U-38 and has the Fred M. Locke marking an the crown. It
looks like it was machine made. The other one of similar style is a light tan
and very crudely made. The top is partially sunk in, the wire groove is not
uniform in depth or width, its base has been "ground off" so it sits
crooked, and it is 1/4" shorter than the other one. This insulator is so
crude you would think it was made by hand. I got it at a flea market for $.25.
The other insulator (at right) seems to be a U-239 [No. it's a U-236, JHT]. I
found six of these in as many shades of brown including one light buff and one
olive drab.
These insulators were on an old telephone line that ran from the old
Headlight Mine on the Trinity River in Trinity, Cal. to the Altoona Mine some 16
miles to the east in steep country. Both mines were operating in the 1870's and
later. The telephone line was put in about 1916.
Can you give me any info on
these insulators? I don't collect porcelains, but I pick up every insulator I
see when I am out looking for the McLaughlin glass insulators I do collect. I'm
a native Californian, and I think the McLaughlin glass is the prettiest of the
West Coast glass.
Royce Hensley
Redding, Cal.
- - - - - - - - - -
Dear Royce:
Your first two
insulators, the Fred M. Locke ponies, are both generally U-39 styles; the U-38
style is a distinctively more dainty variety of the same catalog number. There
is a wide variation in quality and manufacturing methods of these, just as your
specimens indicate.
Regarding the bases (& heights), it was general practice
then to dip the whole insulator in glaze slip and then after drying and before
firing, to prepare the base firing surface by either fettling off the unwanted
rim glaze with a course rag or a belt sander (which removed considerable body
clay). Your photos show a specimen each of both methods.
Regarding the wire
groove, these insulators were plunged (press formed) without the groove, and
thus avoiding the necessity for parting-type dies. Before the clay completely
dried, the wire groove was then cut in with a "green trimming"
machine. Wire grooves thus differ in size and depth. If the insulator didn't fit
squarely on the spindle of the trimming machine, the wire groove can be tilted
or very irregular in size around the insulator.
These U-39 specimens were
made approximately 1902-04, and they have a collector value in the area of $5
each.
The U-239 with "G" marking is a fairly good item also, $3 or so.
This "G" marking is our mystery marking in porcelain insulators. We
have some reasonable guesses as to the manufacturer, but it remains on the
unattributed list at this time. All of the styles with "G" marking are
dry press styles, and their vintage appears to be 1910-1925.
Jack
Dear Jack:
Thanks very much for the information on the Hewletts [See Sept 1979 CJ]. In
glancing again at the May 1979 issue, I noticed the top picture on page 40 shows
a "Guy Wire Breaker". I found 6 of these in that dismal swamp, and
they were being used as normal power insulators. In the middle of one side, each
one has the O-B marking. They are called "Elephant Ears" out here and
are hard to find. What is their value?
Also, the bird in the picture at the
bottom of the same page may be called a "chicken hawk" on Staten
Island, but I am afraid it is what we call a "Turkey Buzzard" down
here in Virginia.
David Turner
Virginia Beach, VA
- - - - - - - - - -
Dear David:
Those
"Elephant Ears" are actually "link strain" insulators. As
opposed to regular gay strain insulators, they are normally used as insulating
breaks when there is a large voltage potential between conductors on opposite
sides of the insulator -- as in many deadending situations. Ohio Brass Co. made
them from about 1909 up until relatively modern times. There was a very early
version with a flat rim all the way around instead of the "ball" edge
as in the rest of them. The early version is a very rare classic (only couple
known at most), whereas the common variety has a collector value of about $6 to
$10 depending on area of the country.
I am afraid the O-B catalog (plus most
collectors) call these "elephant ears" by the name "pork
livers" or "hog livers" for nicknames. But then, I'm also afraid
we call those "chicken hawks" and "turkey buzzards" vultures
out here. I'm fairly good at attributing porcelain insulators, but only if they
don't have feathers.
Jack
Dear Jack:
Enclosed is a photograph of 3
Missouri Pacific (MP) insulators. The only one not in the photo is the white
U-153. I recently completed a trade for 6 dome-marked U-153's and 2 U-610A
cables. The interesting thing is that there is a noticeable difference between
the beehives with the skirt marking or dome marking. The one with skirt marking
(center in photo) appears to be a pure U-153, but the dome-marked one (right in
photo) has a much wider wire groove and appears to be a design all by itself. I
believe the dome-marked is more common, but the skirt-marked may be scarcer than
the U-610A cable style.
I was wondering if the white beehive is skirt-marked or
dome-marked and if you know if it came in both varieties. By the way, I've been
trying to locate some "SOO" beehives and wonder if anyone has
reported any finds of them?
Jim Woods
Galesburg, Ill.
- - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Jim:
Thanks for the
photo and info. I agree with you that the two beehives are different in overall
shape. Don't necessarily consider wire groove differences, since the insulators
are pressed without the grooves, and the groove is later added by trimming the
insulator before the clay, dries. Although the grooves on yours are purposely
different (different specifications and/or use), there is normally quite a large
tolerance on groove height above rim, size and depth.
I think it's a mistake to
rank scarcity of the various MP insulators -- style, glaze, marking position, etc.
Not enough have ever been found from diversified areas to rank them. All are
scarce. I once had about a dozen of the skinny version (the typical U-153) all
from one trade, so that shoots down one of your conjectures. Some were marked on
the dome, others on the skirt, so that shoots down another one. I also once had
a couple of white ones, and I think they were the skinny version, but I can't
recall the positioning of their markings. I never paid much attention to
location or positioning of handstamp markings on porcelains.
Don't know of
anyone at present with some "SOO" beehives to swap, but hopefully one
of our readers will have an extra one and will get in touch with you.
Jack
Dear Jack:
The photo shows an insulator sent to me by a friend in central
New York state. Details are slim, since he can't remember where or how he came
by it.
I have your book "Porcelain Insulators", but can find no
mention of Fargo or a G.S. company. By chance are you familiar with either of
these names? Any information would be appreciated.
I really enjoy your new book
and find it a wealth of knowledge and a pleasure.
Roger L. Berger
P.O. Box 812,
Albany, OR 97321
- - - - - - - - - -
Dear Roger:
Your insulator is a "hanger insulator"
and is used to suspend a three-conductor line from an overhead messenger cable.
The small notches are for tie wires to retain the three cables in the three
large grooves. These and similar hanger insulators are a relatively modern
concept (and currently produced), and their use was spurred by the development
of high strength alumina-porcelain some years ago. They are popularly used in
urban and industrial areas where trees and structures severely limit the space
needed to run lines by conventional crossarm methods. I've seen these in use in
numerous cities, but mostly in eastern areas -- notably N.Y. state. Their
popularity should continue to increase, since this type of line construction can
be much more tidy and less costly than regular crossarm construction.
"Fargo" is a manufacturer of all forms of poleline hardware equipment,
but especially items related to brass or bronze as with the metal fitting on
your item. The "G.S." doesn't ring a bell with me, and I'm horribly
unlucky at matching initials to companies which merely fit the initials.
This
certainly is a spectacular insulator specimen, and you have it beautifully
mounted. Sorry I couldn't be more helpful as to manufacturer or exact vintage.
It certainly is modern -- and possibly a current product.
Jack
Dennis
McHenry (Iowa) has specialized for some time in all the insulators made by
Illinois Electric Porcelain Co., Macomb, Ill. He has recently commenced an
intensive research of all these insulators and hopes to compile a comprehensive
checklist of all the combinations of marking vs. styles, glaze colors, etc. Once
again, I say this will be possible only with the help of all collectors
reporting to Dennis data on their Illinois insulators. The results of his survey
will benefit all of us.
Of particular interest are the Triangle-M markings on
wet process items and the Illinois "map" markings with year dates. For
each one, record the U- number and glaze color. On the Triangle-M markings,
indicate the number and arrangement of the year-coding dots near the top of the
triangle, plus the catalog number (if any) shown underneath the triangle. For
the Map markings, record the year date at the top of the map and the insulator
catalog number (if any) inside the map.
For all other ILLINOIS marking types
record the marking, U- number of the insulator, glaze color. Either refer to the
marking reference numbers in "Porcelain Insulators" book, or make a
simple sketch of the marking.
This is a very worthwhile research project, and I
hope all collectors will take just a little time out to get this data into
Dennis' mail box. If you have any old Illinois catalogs, Dennis would like to
know the date of the catalog together with a quickie list of the U- numbers shown
in the catalog. Address: Dennis McHenry, Trexend, Rt. 1, Bettendorf, IA 52722.
Jack
I missed attending the N.I.A. National Convention this year in Denver, July
20-22, and that was certainly a great letdown for me. We spend most of each
summer at our mountain home in Arizona, usually alternating two weeks there with
one week at Phoenix from mid-May thru September. The back-and-forth schedule
just didn't work out to make it easy to get to Denver without stranding the
family in hot Phoenix.
Each time we return to Phoenix from the mountains, I'm
greeted with a big stack of mail, some of which are your insulator questions. My
apologies for any delays in answers to questions received during my absence.
Getting out the monthly camera-ready porcelain column copy is a tight fit in the
summer schedule, but I try to get it out regularly.
Jack
|